So I love vintage shopping, but buying vintage online felt risky at first. You can’t touch the fabric, see the actual condition or check if it really fits. But… I’ve figured out how to shop vintage online successfully, and honestly, some of my best pieces came from the internet. Let me share what I’ve learned so you can avoid the mistakes I made.
Know your measurements exactly. This is crucial for vintage clothing because sizing has changed dramatically over the decades. A vintage size 10 might be today’s size 4. I keep a note in my phone with my exact measurements—bust, waist, hips, inseam, shoulder width, sleeve length. When sellers provide measurements, I compare them to clothes I already own and love. Don’t trust vintage size tags at all.
Read descriptions obsessively. Good vintage sellers will note every flaw, stain, tear, or sign of wear. I look for detailed descriptions that mention fabric content, measurements, condition, and any issues. If a description is vague or just says “good vintage condition” without specifics, I message the seller with questions or skip it. The best sellers are almost overly detailed.
Zoom in on every photo. I inspect every photo at full size looking for stains, holes, fading, pilling, or damage. Pay special attention to stress points like underarms, crotch seams, elbows, and hems. For furniture, look at joints, finish condition, and any structural issues. If there aren’t enough photos, ask for more before buying.
Understand the return policy before purchasing. Vintage is usually final sale, which is why doing your homework is so important. Some sellers do accept returns, and I’m more willing to take risks with them. But if it’s no returns, I need to be really confident in my purchase. I factor this into what I’m willing to spend.
Check the seller’s reviews and history. On platforms like Etsy, eBay, or Poshmark, I always read reviews. How do they describe condition? Are items as described? Do they ship quickly? How do they handle issues? A seller with hundreds of five-star reviews and detailed positive feedback is usually safe. New sellers or ones with complaints are higher risk.
Know the difference between vintage and vintage-inspired. Some sellers list “vintage style” items that are actually new reproductions. True vintage is generally 20+ years old. If something looks too perfect or there are multiples available, it might be new. This isn’t necessarily bad, but you should know what you’re buying and pay accordingly.
Search multiple platforms. I check Etsy, eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Vestiaire Collective, and even Facebook Marketplace. Each platform has different inventory and pricing. I’ve found the same item on different platforms with wildly different prices. Save searches and check regularly—vintage inventory is constantly changing.
Use specific search terms. Instead of “vintage dress,” try “1960s shift dress” or “vintage midi dress floral.” For furniture, search “mid century credenza walnut” instead of just “vintage cabinet.” The more specific you are, the better your results. Also search for specific brands you love.
Factor in condition when evaluating price. A flawless vintage piece is worth more than one with flaws. I’ll pay premium for excellent condition, but I look for deals on items with minor fixable issues. A dress with a broken zipper that I can replace? Great deal. A sweater with moth holes? Usually not worth it unless it’s really special and cheap.
Ask questions before buying. Good sellers expect questions and are happy to provide more details, measurements, or photos. I’ll ask about fabric stretch, exact condition of a specific area, or whether a piece has any smells. If a seller is annoyed by reasonable questions, that’s a red flag.
Know your era and styles. Learning about different decades helps you identify quality pieces and fair pricing. I studied 1960s and 1970s fashion because that’s what I love, so now I can spot a great authentic piece and know what it should cost. Same with furniture—knowing mid-century modern details helps me avoid reproductions.
Be patient and don’t settle. The beauty of vintage is finding unique pieces, so don’t compromise just to buy something. I have saved searches and check them regularly. When the right piece at the right price pops up, I grab it. But I don’t force it if nothing feels perfect.
Leave a Reply